Eastern Sierra not Eden

San Diego horse lover discovers bizarre crime

Fire-bombed  truck
  • Fire-bombed truck

When former Allied Gardens resident, Shelly Snoderly, walked into the Big Pine Saddle Club early one morning, three months ago, she was upset to see the place had been ransacked. Saddles and tack were obviously missing in the 41-stable horse facility. A truck had been fire bombed.

Choco, the horse most severely injured in attack.

Choco, the horse most severely injured in attack.

It was utter shock when she then discovered the unthinkable. Snoderly found nine mutilated and beaten horses and mules. Seven slashed in their throats and legs.

Located in the large, rural county of Inyo, in California’s Eastern Sierra, the Saddle Club, with help from the small town of 1,700, immediately offered a reward of $5,000.

Snoderly, who grew up in Big Pine, couldn’t remember any acts like the attack on the stables. In 2017, Inyo County reported only 128 violent crimes and no homicides.

Several San Diego-area residents, who knew Snoderly from her 16 years living in San Diego, and the boarding of her two horses at Blanco Ranch in San Ysidro, rallied around her and her club, in which she serves as president. The reward fund grew to $10,000.

Dawn Morris, of Santee, was one of them. She knew making the six-hour drive up Highway 395 to Big Pine wouldn’t help. “So I donated [to the Reward Fund],” said Morris. “I then went on Facebook and other social media to rally San Diego animal lovers.”

“We volunteer at the San Diego Humane Society. We rescue animals. We just love animals. I thought it was awful, and wanted to get the word out,” said Morris.

As of this week, the reward leading to an arrest is now up to almost $19,000.

However over the last three months, Inyo County Sheriff’s Dept. has been mum on the investigation, initially saying they had no leads and were not asking for help from outside agencies (FBI, Homeland Security, or American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals). Surprising, because those agencies would have powers of investigation and arrest in such a bizarre crime. “What if it happened in other areas?” Snoderly originally questioned.

Over the last months, frustration with lack of information from the Sheriff’s Dept. could be read in the pages of a Mammoth Lakes newspaper, The Sheet. Publisher Ted Charlton had lamented in his published columns that the lack of updates in the case is disconcerting.

However Snoderly reported to me on October 18 that the sheriffs now report they have some possible suspects but need to wait on solid evidence being processed in the Orange County’s crime lab.

The Sheet’s Charlton updated me on his knowledge of the investigation. “These are very bad guys with a long history of violence. People were afraid to talk, thinking they might be killed. If these guys can kill one guy, they’re capable of killing ten,” he advised. “Even some of our deputies were hesitant in talking about it.”

Snoderly said all the animals have now recovered from their attack, including Choco, the horse most severely injured in his attack. Snoderly’s two horses, which she had brought up from San Diego, were not injured.

Share / Tools

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • AddThis
  • Email

More from SDReader


Oh great! The cops are afraid of those they think dunnit. Anyone who assumes that crime in rural areas is minor need to think again. That newspaper editor is nervy in just pointing out the lack of progress. Oh, and what if there is no evidence revealed by the crime lab? Back to Square One?

Reportedly they have the evidence and know the suspects. The OC lab report will be the evidence they need to convict. They know its there, just Inyo County doesn't have the lab and technology.

STORY UPDATE: From The Sheet newspaper 11/16/18 Horse case cold Several months have passed since the throats of several horses were cut and a pickup was set on fire on the night of July 3 at the Big Pine Saddle Club. Inyo County Sherif Jef Hollowell told Te Sheet this week that there is nothing new to report concerning the investigation.

“We haven’t received any credible new information. Te leads that have been coming in have been thoroughly investigated. As for the lab/DNA results, the items we sent to the lab for evidence collection didn’t reveal any DNA. We are following up on any information received, but have no solid leads,” Hollowell concluded. Te promise of an $18,000 reward has not loosened any lips. -Maddux

Log in to comment

Skip Ad

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader