You want rent control in San Diego? Sign here.

Meeting draws only three, but hopes for movement are high

Rafael Bautista (center) will soon help take the fight to Encinitas.
  • Rafael Bautista (center) will soon help take the fight to Encinitas.

“I’m paying $950 [for rent per month] there, and I’m keeping my fingers crossed [that it doesn’t go up],” said Cat Mendoza on August 26. She lives off of 44th Street in City Heights, just a couple blocks away from the “Know Your Tenants Rights/Conozca sus Derechos de Inquilino” meeting that she attended with three others.

“It’s increased from $700 [per month],” said Mendoza, 32, “and it’s comparatively lower than certain areas — but we still have a lot of stuff that needs to be fixed.”

Rent control petition

Rent control petition

She, like others in City Heights, have been coming to Rafael Bautista for advice regarding their rentals and their rights as tenants.

Bautista, also a lifelong City Heights resident, headed the 1–3 p.m. discussion last Saturday at 4010 Fairmount Avenue. He is a real estate broker and one of the founders of the San Diego Tenants United (SDTU), a group that started a petition to “implement rent control in San Diego” to be delivered to the San Diego City Council and the mayor’s office once its reaches 7500 votes.

“We are building a tenants’ union and a housing-rights movement,” he posted on his public invitation. “We are fighting to end homelessness, implement rent control, and end displacement. Join us as we supply our local communities with the knowledge they need and prepare them for the long struggle ahead with local abusive landlords, policies, and tactics they will face.”

One of the attendees, Gabriel Martinez, had to leave the meeting early. “I definitely think we need rent control in San Diego,” said Martinez, a 22-year-old UCSD political science student. “We are paying $1800 for our place in Chula Vista — that’s the cheapest place we could find."

Bautista took part in the Village Apartments protest in Linda Vista covered by the Reader last year.

“The [Village Apartments] were built maybe in the 1950s,” Bautista said. “Like old military housing with the same paint, same flooring. The windows wouldn’t close and some of them had holes — they were terrible.”

Tenants' demand sheet

Tenants' demand sheet

Bautista said the San Diego Socialist Campaign, International Socialist Organization, United Against Police Terror, Raices Sin Fronteras, Party for Socialism and Liberation, Collectivo Zapatista, and the National Action Network have helped guide the Linda Vista tenants’ fight for the improvements of their rentals located at 6948 Eastman Street.

They created demands on paper that were signed and delivered to the apartment management company.

“[The Village Apartments management company] responded on paper with what they were going to do,” he said. “But things weren’t fixed so fast.”

After a few protests "led by the tenants and SDTU" and a couple more meetings, contractors started repairing the units.

Recently, though, the tenants “started organizing because they were getting five months of late fees all at once. Management had changed the terms of the lease agreement and had changed due dates of their rent payments from the fifth of the month to the third,” Bautista said. “Most people didn’t even know until they got several months of late fees due at once. Some [tenants] got, like, $500 in dues out of the blue, and [that’s when] they contacted us.”

Bautista said he helped get the late fees rescinded but shortly thereafter the tenants received notices of rate increases. “[One increase was] from $1200 to $1600 to a tenant who was moved from a one-bedroom to a two-bedroom because her unit was mold-infested.”

While Bautista was telling the Linda Vista story to the three individuals on August 26, David M. walked in and joined the discussion. He had been present at a few of the Village Apartments meetings and protests.

“Those people [Village Apartments tenants] are driving the whole thing,” David said. “Seventy [tenants] with all of their kids come to the [property management] meetings.”

Bautista and David said this week they and other rent-control advocates expect to receive a notification from the Village Apartments management company on their proposed 2 percent rent increase every two years (approved by tenants).

“A lot of the stuff we are doing are like models,” Bautista said. “We want the tenants to develop over there so they can carry that [method of negotiation with their landlords] to the other buildings.”

While the “increase in rent has affected the displacement of homelessness” according to Bautista, it also has displaced other San Diegans.

Giovany Simiano and Paul are two former San Diego residents affected by rent increases. They couldn’t make it to Bautista’s meeting because they were a part of “the San Diego exodus.”

Simiano is an American graphic designer who used to live in Chula Vista. He moved his residence and business operation close to Playas de Tijuana.

“I got a four-bedroom house [with] two stories, a garage, and a patio for $450,” he said. “Our water bill is $25 a month and light [electricity] about $50 a month. Right now there are a lot of [American] people that work in San Diego and live here.”

Paul is a veteran who recently moved to Murrieta. “My rent [in Lakeside for a two-bedroom apartment] was increased from $995 [in 2015] to $1195 [in May].” He is now living with his brother, also a former San Diegan; they bought an almost-new 3000-square-foot home for under $400,000, “…which can buy a smaller and older house in Encanto,” he scoffed.

Bautista said “the cheapest San Diego rentals are in Encanto, and then City Heights.”

Bautista showed the group a sample of the rent-control petition sheet on which he had garnered about 700 handwritten signatures. His online petition had about 6200 signatures at press time. “We expect to reach our goal by November,” he said.

A copy of the list of demands that was given to Village Apartments management was passed out to the three attendees.

The next city Bautista is working on is further north. “We have a lawsuit against Encinitas,” he said. “Encinitas has fallen behind on implementing a housing plan that allows for low-income housing.”

Share / Tools

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • AddThis
  • Email

More from SDReader


Let's have full rent control. When there are too many renters, landlords can't jack up rents. When there are too many vacancies, tenants have to pay full price anyway. One-way rent control is unfair.

The problem is not the amount of rent the problem is that wages have not kept pace with the cost of living in San Diego. San Diego employers have always relied on low wage workers who lived in low rent neighborhoods and TJ. What used to be affordable areas now cost more than most who work by the hour can afford. Most of the employers in the hotel, restaurant, retail industries rely on government programs to provide their employees with housing, food, medical, etc. San Diego will become more and more a two class society with the so called middle class becoming part of the working poor.

Exactly! Many of us are getting by on an income equal to what we could earn 20 years ago - whether we were working then or not. Not just low-pay workers but people who would have been in the middle class if it hadn't shrunk violently. Outside of tech and government, it's almost impossible to find a job that pays $20 an hour or more, and that's what it takes to be able to live decently here. (Nothing against tech or government, BTW.) The median income is up just $170 a week since 2007, but with cost of living factored in, it's more like $14. https://www.bls.gov/cps/cpsaat39.htm https://www.bls.gov/cps/earnings.htm

I can't see rent control being passed by the City Council. Landlords will just increase their payola to make sure it doesn't happen.

One other thing: larger apartment complexes are being bought up by real estate investment trusts - foreign and national - at a fast pace. (Thank you for the info, SD Business Journal).That's part of why developers are building so many rentals. They can sell them quickly to investors. For investors here, the profit is reliable, and goes up at least 5% a year and the tax write downs are enormous. http://www.dividend.com/dividend-stocks/financial/reit-residential/ That causes two problems. One is that rents are going to start high and go up 5% a year. The other is that it flattens the number of housing units for buyers, who often start at condos in expensive places like San Diego. Home ownership used to be the way the middle class saved and grew money for retirement. As housing moves to rentals - at a high price - that passive way for regular people to grow money will become rarer.

Log in to comment

Skip Ad

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader