Imperial Beach pulls in its horns

Not the Welcoming City it hoped to be

The mayor of Imperial Beach has retracted the Welcoming City proclamation that the city council issued in mid-August after protests at council meetings.

"I am retracting the Welcoming City proclamation due to its policy directive that should have been subject to city council, city staff and public review through a city council resolution," Mayor Serge Dedina said in a formal statement on September 23, five weeks after issuing the proclamation.

Dedina added that he made the retraction "after carefully listening to residents, city councilmembers, city staff, and the city attorney at the recent city council meeting and Open Air Open House City Forum, and to underscore my commitment to open and transparent government."

City manager Andy Hall had no comment about how the proclamation, which had been acknowledged as only a gesture and did not carry the force of law, was a "policy directive" that now needed a "city council resolution."

The Welcoming City proclamation, presented during a council meeting in mid-August, was intended to officially welcome immigrants, refugees, and asylum seekers in Imperial Beach. At the time, Dedina pointed out that immigrants already account for one-fifth of Imperial Beach.

One local resident, an active supporter of the mayor and the proclamation, said the retraction makes her fear living in Imperial Beach.

"Now I am afraid of my own city," said Victoria Mejia Fallon. "Even though the mayor still believes this city should be a welcome city, he retracted from that and us, the immigrants that make this city."

Tim O'Neal, a current candidate for Imperial Beach city council who has been called out on the issue by conservative activists on social media, speculated that the language in the proclamation saying the mayor would "direct city departments" might have been a reason that it had to be retracted, even though in Imperial Beach the mayor doesn't have the authority to do that anyway.

"What most IB residents don't know is the mayor and city council cannot 'direct' staff to do anything," O'Neal said. "Only the city manager can 'direct' city staff. The mayor and council are strictly policymakers."

Despite that, the reaction has been intense, including an anonymous "Recall Mayor Serge Dedina" Facebook page, articles in national media outlets, Youtube videos saying that the city council members "welcome ISIS" and irate protesters at a city council meeting.

The protesters at the Sept. 21 meeting booed the mayor's father as he spoke about being a refugee from Nazi Germany and said the U.S. should let in more refugees. Many of the anti-proclamation crowd held up printed "No ISIS" signs.

According to one witness at the council meeting, there was a "riot" outside the council room.

"The riot could be heard from inside city hall meeting building. Yelling and screaming. The sheriffs had to go outside and disperse the crowd," Cheryl Quinones, a candidate for the board of the South Bay Union Elementary School District, said on social media.

A former Missouri Tea Party celebrity that now lives in Imperial Beach, Gina Loudon, wrote a mid-September article on the website World News Daily in which she called out the Imperial Beach mayor for "a scheme to flood communities in the United States with as many immigrants as possible, legal and illegal, without regard to resist [sic] public safety and public health," and called the proclamation "worse" than Sanctuary City legislation. (Her husband, John Loudon, said at a council meeting that the proclamation was part of a "hidden political agenda" to bring refugees "from Africa" into Imperial Beach.)

Many of the protesters also held "No Sanctuary City" signs at the Sept. 21 council meeting.

("Sanctuary Cities," which have legal policies to not prosecute people solely for their nonlegal residency status and are designed to encourage them to be able to report crimes and otherwise participate in society, have been targeted by talk shows and other conservative outlets.)

“It’s not a resolution, it’s not an ordinance and it’s not binding on the city,” said city attorney Jennifer Lyon, according to published reports. “The effect of it is that it didn’t create any new laws, it didn’t create any obligations on behalf of the city.”

When Dedina issued the proclamation during an emotional city council presentation in mid-August, he said, "This means a lot to me.... My dad came to this country in 1939 as a refugee. He escaped the Nazi occupation of Europe. My mom was bombed by the Germans and ended up coming to America.... Our beach has become the Ellis Island and town square of America."

Share / Tools

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • AddThis
  • Email

More from SDReader


Syria is in a civil war. It is nowhere near the evil empire that Hitler created. I wonder how many men left America during the civil war? Perhaps if they had smart phones back then and saw an easy way out, they would have fled. I see the men that leave Syria as cowards. That's all I have to say about that. That, and we should not be accepting any immigrants or refugees until we take care of what we have already, our vets, homeless and fixing our infrastructure.

Every citizen has a responsibility to his community: his friends and neighbors, his co-workers, his PTA group, his city state and country. Many people in our County take this responsibility seriously. We study the issues and vote and occasionally speak out on an issue of concern.

Ponzi suggests that immigrants are not taking responsibility for their community. They are shirking their duty and we should not give them comfort. We should encourage them to fight for what's right in their own domain. Perhaps we should give them money or weapons if their struggle seems just. But we should not invite them here for a life of luxury and irresponsibility.

I think there are exceptions such as journalists who face extreme danger, scholars who teach ideas that the power elite don't agree with, and other activists who have put themselves in peril.

In fact, I find that citizens who prefer to invest in mindless entertainment rather than citizenship matters are despicable. Every sports fan who is not an informed voter should be shot at sunrise. It doesn't matter if they are American or Syrian. Nobody is exempt from their duties to their community.

And generally I think Ponzi has a good point. But some day I hope that national and other borders will become irrelevant and we will all work toward a common cause.

Log in to comment

Skip Ad

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader