Cops and jobbers

Mayor Faulconer needs a new citizen watchdog to keep an eye on police.
  • Mayor Faulconer needs a new citizen watchdog to keep an eye on police.

Mayor Kevin Faulconer is looking for a new executive director for San Diego’s much-maligned police review board. Two years ago the body, officially known as the Citizens’ Review Board on Police Practices, came in for knocks by the county grand jury, which charged that it was rife with “prejudice, fear and intimidation,” and bullied into submission by the very cops it was intended to oversee. Then-acting chairman Jim Kaese complained that the jury did not consult him before it issued its report. He fired back: “A lack of time is the primary reason for member turnover, not intimidation.”

In their official response to the findings, boardmembers denied they had been customarily rowdy, at least not in public. “There is no lack of decorum among Board members in open session when members of the public are present. The CRB listens respectfully to all public comments and conducts its business in a straightforward manner. In the past, there have been times when a lack of decorum in closed sessions has occurred during discussion of individual cases. One member in particular was placed on probation for aggressive, argumentative, mean-spirited questioning and no longer serves on the Board.”

Danell Scarborough, executive director of the city’s Human Relations Commission, is currently doing double-duty as the review board’s chief executive. With Faulconer already believed to be eyeing higher office somewhere down the line, running a tight ship at the review board is said by insiders to be worth the so-far unspecified cost to taxpayers of hiring yet another hand to run it.

City hall cynics note that the mayor, whose election was backed by the San Diego Police Officers Association, is likely to give the labor group final veto power over the ultimate selection. According to the job notice posted on the city’s website, “the ideal candidate will have proven leadership qualities with the ability to build relationships of trust, respect, and credibility in the community. Often acting with a high level of independence, and visibility, the ability to build consensus, advocate for change, foster teamwork, and promote openness, fairness, and integrity is critical.”

Also helpful: “Well developed facilitation skills to help resolve differences between Board Members as well as between the Board and San Diego Police Department,” and “a high level of political acumen and ability to operate in an apolitical manner.” Résumés are due July 10.

Share / Tools

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • AddThis
  • Email

More from SDReader


The Citizens' Review Board (CRB) on Police Practices serves a single purpose: To ensure that City of San Diego Police Department (SDPD) cops are able to abuse the public as they please.

The CRB does not represent the citizens. Its idea of a "review" is to agree with whatever SDPD Internal Affairs (IA) says, and the cops at IA ensure that their colleagues on the force are protected from legal action for abusing the public.

The CRB is a complete sham. KEVIN FAULCONER is part of that very problem, as his people (including chief of staff STEPHEN PUETZ, deputy chief of staff FELIPE MONROIG, and JOHN LY) have refused to do anything about corruption in the CRB and in IA despite substantive evidence and repeated written notifications.

TODD GLORIA was no better. As city council president and later as interim mayor, his people (including chief of staff JAMIE FOX and executive assistant M. VANESSA JACKSON) also protected the CRB and IA and ignored repeated correspondence on this matter. On 2013-08-15 Jackson told me by email that "We cannot get involved in pending investigations unless directed by the City Attorney". In response, I asked Jackson for proof that the City Attorney "directed" Todd Gloria and the rest of the members of the City Council to "get involved" in the Filner case while several "pending investigations" were in progress. Jackson never replied.

The CRB's executive director DANELL SCARBOROUGH strings complainants along endlessly with empty promises that a real investigation is occurring while knowing full well that (1) the CRB works in concert with IA to cover-up police corruption and (2) the CRB merely rubber-stamps IA's habitual exonerations of dirty cops.

Chamber of Commerce president, ex-Mayor and former Police chief Jerry Sanders has only two more days to apply to become head the Citizens Review Board on Police Practices.

Log in to comment

Skip Ad

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader