The Eagle Is Totally Masculine

As the hero in The Eagle, Channing Tatum has the firm-jawed look of meat with a mission.
  • As the hero in The Eagle, Channing Tatum has the firm-jawed look of meat with a mission.

My invaluable but doomed-to-be-forgotten thoughts about the Oscars must wait until the Reader before the big night on February 27. The news of this year’s San Diego Jewish Film Festival can wait until later in this column. First, we march on imperial business:

The Eagle

Part of every man — at least every man who ever wanted to wear a metal breastplate into battle — thrills to any film about Roman legionnaires. After all, didn’t John Wayne play one in The Greatest Story Ever Told? We needed Centurion, and The Last Legion (starring a stutter-free Colin Firth), and now we need The Eagle. Strap on your sandals, lash on your armor, and grab your gladius (short sword)!

Currently seen in The Dilemma, Channing Tatum is a new Ashton Kutcher (not a compliment). But he satisfies the narrow, robust demands of The Eagle. He stars as Marcus Flavius Aquila (“aquila” is Latin for eagle). Maybe his name should be Buffus Brawnicus Macho. His physique bulks up a story that — with dialogue such as “Damn the dark” and “We fought back to back, pissing where we stood” — will not eclipse Caesar’s memoirs of the Gallic wars.

Sent to command a frontier garrison in Britannia, Marcus seeks to avenge his dead father who led a legion butchered there 20 years earlier. Its golden-eagle standard was taken by the rude, hairy, sometimes blue-painted Brits now foraging and fuming north of Hadrian’s Wall. Director Kevin Macdonald certainly knows barbarians, having made films about Idi Amin Dada (The Last King of Scotland) and Mick Jagger (Being Mick). But these are patriotic brutes, from whom the equally proud Marcus is keen to retrieve the eagle. His uncle (Donald Sutherland) sags into his toga at the thought, but young Marcus is good to go. Tatum has the firm-jawed look of meat with a mission.

Northward he goes with Esca, a bright, bilingual, and British slave (Jamie Bell, almost as gutsy as when ballet dancing in Billy Elliot).This totally masculine story was adapted by Jeremy Brock from novels by (surprise) a woman, Rosemary Sutcliff, first filmed for British TV in the ’70s. Finely photographed by Anthony Dod Mantle, the movie makes good use of raw, chilly landscapes, never strays into tangents, doesn’t sermonize about Christianity, and lets us hear early-Scottish gibberish. The fearful, sword-based combat seems real enough, though I wish that less of the close action was rushed by rapid, hurly-burly editing.

The Eagle is more primordial than classical, and its gritty grip never becomes a history lecture like Anthony Mann’s Fall of the Roman Empire, a stately but depressing epic in which many famous actors emulate marble columns. The relevant history is less Roman than cinematic. Those alert to it will hear the bugle call of John Ford’s Fort Apache saluting his Drums Along the Mohawk, echoes of Northwest Passage, A Man Called Horse, Black Robe, and The Last of the Mohicans, even some bagpipe music wafting in from the Scottish military drama Tunes of Glory. On February 27, The Eagle will close the Glasgow Film Festival, perhaps stirring the natives to thoughts of revolt.



Winston Churchill, who during World War II became Britain’s greatest prime minister, had hundreds of toy soldiers as a boy. Mark Hogancamp survived his own war — a vicious beating by bar thugs — and after surgery and rehab found therapy by dressing Ken and Barbie dolls in WWII outfits. In Kingston, New York, they inhabit his toy-scaled, wartime village of Marwencol, Belgium. There, little German and Allied soldiers frequent a tavern and watch female “catfights.” We come to see that the Nazi troops are voodoo dolls for the fury beneath Mark’s mild-mannered surface, and his hero, himself, is like a plastic Lee Marvin from The Dirty Dozen.

The respectfully voyeuristic documentary Marwencol probes this domain where Barbies kick Nazi butt. The beating ravaged Hogancamp’s memory, ended his marriage, his job, his drinking, and the sometimes-morbid drawings that fill much of his old diary. Mark has transformed the trauma by photographing the miniature dramas that he stages, channeling his life and friends (most of them feel flattered). Director Jeff Malmberg endorses the vision by filming Mark’s dolls and his photos so that they often fill the frame.

The thin line between real and fantastic blurs, even when Mark simply walks down a road pulling a small wagon of dolls. His most sensitive side is vented not by the warriors, but by the women (“My girls know me better than I know me”). You may groan a bit when the Manhattan art world discovers Mark, and he gets a gallery show. But Malmberg is not ironic, patronizing, or belittling. The costumed kitsch resonates, and Marwencol is a rather heroic, if not exactly Churchillian, homage to creative survival.


The Jewish Film Festival

At age 21, the San Diego Jewish Film Festival can claim maturity. Largely led by women, it has long been among the most adult, diverse, and smartly cosmopolitan of local film events.

Spawned by the Lawrence Family Jewish Community Center and the San Diego Center for Jewish Culture, this year’s event occurs February 10 to 20. The festival has left its familiar home, the AMC La Jolla 12, for a new hub: the Reading Cinemas Town Square 14 in Clairemont, 4665 Clairemont Drive. Other new sites are the Carlsbad Village Theatre and the Edwards San Marcos Stadium 18. A few events will occur at the Garfield Theater at the JCC and UltraStar’s Mission Valley 7 (Hazard Center).

Festival producer Sandra Kraus promises “More West Coast and California premieres than ever before” and adds, with a realistic nod to commercial booking practices, “You may never have the opportunity to see these films again!” Over 40 works are scheduled, the opener being this Thursday’s German film Berlin 36, Kaspar Heidelbach’s story of Gretel Bergmann (Karoline Herfurth), a Jewish athlete who challenged the Nazi co-option of the Olympic Games. That’s at 4 p.m. at the Hazard; 7 p.m. at the Clairemont.

Other films related to the WWII/Holocaust era are Army of Crime, about foreigners who fought for French honor; Habermann, about Germans and Czechs opposing the Nazi takeover of the Sudetenland; the documentary of a scientific survivor, In Search of Memory: The Neuroscientist Eric Kandel; the tale of a deaf, signing survivor, Ingelore; a French Jewish boy’s heroic endurance in La Rafle, with Jean Reno and Melanie Laurent; an artist enshrining his lost Jewish world in Paint What You Remember; a noir about a secretly Jewish movie star, Protektor; and a satire on a fabled Jewish boxer, Max Baer’s Last Right Hook.

Other film topics include a Down syndrome mom in Anita; the first Israeli astronaut in An Article of Hope; postwar “mail-order” brides in Bride Flight; a wrestler and painter in Canvasman: The Robbie Ellis Story; a moral crusader in Grace Paley: Collected Shorts; a gay Klezmer musician in He’s My Girl; the rewards of longevity in Over 90 and Loving It (which includes San Diego’s Laura Simon, 105); a kibbutz true to its roots in Inventing Our Life; the Civil War in Jewish Soldiers in Blue & Gray; Jewish victims of Argentina’s “dirty war” in Our Disappeared; a Spanish Civil War hero in Visa al Paraíso; the scandal of eugenics in War Against the Weak; and two baseball films: The Yankles and Jews and Baseball: An American Love Story.

The curtain falls Sunday, February 20, with Who Do You Love, Jerry Zaks’s dramatized salute to innovative record producers Leonard and Phil Chess. There will be numerous guests, shorts, speakers and events. Most tickets are from $11 to $13. Consult sdjff.org.

Newsreel: A small tear for Maria Schneider, 58, who died on February 3. “I felt very sad because I was treated like a sex symbol,” said the French woman who, barely a trained actor, came to fame at 19 as Marlon Brando’s pick-up lover in Last Tango in Paris. After the film’s rape scene and Pauline Kael comparing the film’s impact to Stravinsky’s “Rite of Spring” debut, wasn’t that fate a foregone conclusion? But her performances in Tango and in The Passenger, with Jack Nicholson, were quite unforgettable. ■

Reviewed in this week’s movie listings: Sanctum and Gnomeo & Juliet.

Also featured this week: John Rubio interviews Channing Tatum

Share / Tools

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • AddThis
  • Email

More from SDReader


help me here people:

what word is used to describe someone who tries to write eloquently and impressively but just ends up sounding like a middle aged housewife who is "blossoming"?

Hey, I'll take a shot (see my hit show on TLC) at this. I'm well aware of the middle-aged housewife blossomythingy stuff 'cause that goldang lamestream media is all over me 24/7, donhca know?

Is it "cannell"?

Log in to comment

Skip Ad

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader