First Man 1.0 stars

Movie poster


Gravity used space to explore the existential alienation brought on by the death of a child. The Martian used space to explore human ingenuity and drive at the level of nuts and bolts and chemistry. Director Damien Chazelle’s latest gives us a mashup of the two that is sadly less engaging than either, and not just because it hews to the real-life story of the United States’ space program and astronaut Neil Armstrong. Why go to space? Early on, Armstrong says it’s worth doing for a change of perspective — and heaven knows the grieving dad needs one. But the film’s focus on his personal mission — the rest of the team mostly seems intent on beating the Russians — has the dramatic effect of making all the consequent expense and sacrifice about Armstrong and his sadness, which is, of course, crazily solipsistic. As for the nitty-gritty nuts-and-bolts, we get to see plenty of problems, but not much problem-solving. And while the big finish is appropriately big, star Ryan Gosling’s impassive visage must have the gravitational pull of a black hole, because Chazelle can’t seem to keep his camera from being pulled loose from its moorings and drawn in thisclose for more than one or two scenes at a time. That’s fine during the tense opening, as Armstrong bounces a rocket plane off the earth’s atmosphere. Back on earth, it gets old fast.

Matthew Lickona

Length: 2 hours, 18 minutes

Rated: PG-13

View trailer


I look for your comments every week on Rotten Tomatoes. I have never seen a positive review from you - EVER. Do you always look for the most negative thing you can find? You must be a curmudgeon. Bah humbug!

Hi, thanks much for reading. Here's my page at Rotten Tomatoes: Of the last 50 movies I've reviewed, only half are rotten. I go into every movie I review hoping to like it, promise.

It seems that out of the 634 films you have reviewed, not a single one has achieved your highest possible score of five stars. What could it possibly take, then, Mr. Lickona, to satisfy your almost impossibly exacting standards?

Log in to comment

Skip Ad